Skip to main content
Expert VPN Testing Methodology

How We Test VPNs: Expert Methodology & Review Process

Updated: October 15, 2025 AMTSO Certified Process 5-7 Days Per Review

Standardized methodology ensuring fair, accurate, and comprehensive VPN evaluations. Our rigorous testing process includes speed benchmarks, security audits, privacy analysis, and real-world performance testing.

12 min read Expert Analysis Fact Checked

Our VPN Testing Process

Standardized methodology ensuring fair, accurate, and comprehensive VPN evaluations using industry-standard protocols and testing procedures.

Initial Setup & Configuration

We test each VPN on clean systems using standardized hardware configurations. All VPNs are installed with default settings and optimal protocols selected.

System Requirements

Windows 11, macOS Sonoma, iOS 17, Android 14 with standardized network connections (1 Gbps fiber) and clean system installations for each test.

Testing Duration

Our comprehensive VPN testing process takes approximately 5-7 days per service, including 48 hours of continuous monitoring and analysis.

Performance Benchmarking

Comprehensive speed testing across multiple servers, protocols, and time periods to assess real-world performance under various conditions.

  • Ookla Speedtest, Fast.com, custom speed tools
  • 10 tests per server, averaged results
  • Peak and off-peak hour testing

Security & Privacy Audit

Rigorous testing for DNS leaks, IP leaks, kill switch functionality, and encryption protocol strength to verify security claims.

  • DNSLeakTest.com, IPLeak.net, BrowserLeaks.com
  • Kill switch stress testing
  • Protocol security analysis

Feature Testing & Usability

Comprehensive evaluation of all VPN features, app usability, customer support quality, and compatibility across devices.

  • Feature testing on all supported platforms
  • Customer support response time testing
  • User experience and interface evaluation

Privacy Policy Analysis

Legal and technical review of privacy policies, logging practices, jurisdiction analysis, and third-party audit verification.

  • Privacy policy comprehensive review
  • Third-party audit report analysis
  • Jurisdiction and legal compliance check

Scoring & Final Review

Results compiled using our standardized scoring system, with comprehensive write-up highlighting strengths, weaknesses, and recommendations.

  • Weighted scoring across all categories
  • Peer review and verification process
  • Regular review updates and retesting

Speed & Performance Testing Protocol

Detailed methodology for measuring VPN impact on connection speed and latency using industry-standard tools and procedures.

Testing Environment & Equipment

Our speed testing is conducted in a controlled environment to ensure consistency and accuracy across all VPN reviews:

Internet Connection

Dedicated 1 Gbps fiber connection with consistent baseline speeds

Testing Hardware

Standardized Windows 11 and macOS Sonoma systems with identical specifications

Network Isolation

Dedicated testing network with no competing traffic

Testing Times

Tests conducted during both peak (7-9 PM local) and off-peak (2-4 AM local) hours

Speed Testing Methodology

Each VPN undergoes the following standardized speed testing process:

  • Baseline Establishment: 10 speed tests conducted without VPN to establish baseline performance
  • Server Selection: Testing across 3 server categories:
    • Nearby servers (same country/region)
    • International servers (different continents)
    • Popular streaming servers (US, UK, Canada)
  • Protocol Testing: Each server tested with all available protocols (OpenVPN, WireGuard, IKEv2, proprietary)
  • Multiple Test Runs: 10 speed tests per server/protocol combination, results averaged
  • Reconnection Testing: VPN disconnected and reconnected after every 5th test to simulate real usage

Testing Tools & Metrics

We use multiple speed testing tools to ensure accuracy and eliminate tool-specific biases:

  • Primary Tool: Ookla Speedtest (most widely recognized standard)
  • Secondary Tool: Fast.com (Netflix CDN testing for streaming performance)
  • Tertiary Tool: Custom speed testing scripts for consistency verification
  • Metrics Measured: Download speed, Upload speed, Ping/Latency, Jitter, Packet loss

Industry Standard

We follow AMTSO (Anti-Malware Testing Standards Organization) VPN Performance Testing Guidelines, the first industry-standard methodology for VPN testing published in February 2025.

Security & Privacy Testing Protocols

Comprehensive security auditing to verify VPN protection claims using advanced testing tools and methodologies.

DNS Leak Testing

DNS leaks are one of the most critical VPN vulnerabilities. Our testing protocol includes:

  • Standard DNS Leak Test: Using DNSLeakTest.com and IPLeak.net to identify DNS server locations
  • Extended DNS Leak Test: Advanced testing with multiple DNS queries to detect intermittent leaks
  • IPv6 Leak Detection: Specific testing for IPv6 DNS leaks, which many VPNs fail to block
  • Multiple Test Scenarios:
    • Fresh connection testing
    • Connection drop and reconnect scenarios
    • Network interface switching (WiFi to Ethernet)
    • System reboot with auto-connect enabled

Kill Switch Testing

Kill switch reliability is crucial for maintaining privacy. We conduct comprehensive kill switch testing:

  • Connection Termination Test: Forcibly ending VPN process to test kill switch activation
  • Network Interface Test: Disconnecting and reconnecting network adapters
  • System Reboot Test: The most challenging test - verifying kill switch functionality during system startup
  • Traffic Monitoring: Using Wireshark to capture all network traffic and identify any unencrypted leaks
  • Multiple Scenario Testing: Testing kill switch under various failure conditions

WebRTC & IP Leak Testing

Additional leak testing covers other potential privacy vulnerabilities:

  • WebRTC Leak Testing: Using BrowserLeaks.com to test for WebRTC IP address leaks
  • IP Address Verification: Confirming all web traffic shows VPN server IP addresses
  • Geolocation Testing: Verifying that websites detect the VPN server location, not real location
  • Torrent IP Testing: For P2P-enabled VPNs, testing IP address exposure during torrenting

Encryption & Protocol Security

We analyze the cryptographic strength and implementation of VPN protocols:

  • Encryption Analysis: Verifying encryption strength (AES-256, ChaCha20) and implementation
  • Protocol Security Review: Assessing security of supported protocols (OpenVPN, WireGuard, IKEv2)
  • Cipher Suite Analysis: Reviewing available cipher suites and default configurations
  • Perfect Forward Secrecy: Verifying PFS implementation in key exchange

Server Network Evaluation

Comprehensive assessment of server infrastructure and global network coverage to evaluate real-world performance and reliability.

Server Network Analysis

We evaluate each VPN's server infrastructure across multiple criteria:

  • Geographic Coverage: Number of countries and cities with server presence
  • Server Count Verification: Confirming claimed server numbers through direct testing
  • Server Types: Assessment of physical vs. virtual servers, dedicated vs. shared
  • Specialty Servers: Testing of P2P-optimized, streaming-optimized, and obfuscated servers
  • Server Load Testing: Monitoring server performance under different load conditions

Connection Reliability Testing

Server stability and reliability are tested through:

  • Connection Success Rate: Percentage of successful connections across all tested servers
  • Connection Time: Average time to establish VPN connections
  • Disconnection Frequency: Monitoring for unexpected disconnections during testing
  • Automatic Reconnection: Testing automatic reconnect functionality after connection drops
  • Server Switching: Evaluating ease and speed of switching between servers

Streaming & P2P Capability Testing

Specialized server testing for specific use cases:

  • Streaming Service Access: Testing ability to unblock Netflix, BBC iPlayer, Hulu, Disney+
  • Streaming Quality: Video quality and buffering assessment
  • P2P Performance: BitTorrent speed testing on P2P-enabled servers
  • Port Forwarding: Testing port forwarding functionality where available

Review Scoring Methodology

Transparent weighted scoring system for fair VPN comparisons based on technical performance and user value.

Our VPN reviews use a weighted scoring system across five main categories. Each category contributes to the overall score based on importance to typical VPN users:

Category Weight Scoring Criteria Excellent (4.5-5.0) Good (3.5-4.4) Fair (2.5-3.4) Poor (1.0-2.4)
Security & Privacy 30% No-logs policy, encryption, leak protection, kill switch reliability Military-grade encryption, verified no-logs, perfect leak protection Strong encryption, credible no-logs policy, minimal leaks Adequate encryption, questionable logging, some leaks Weak encryption, logging concerns, frequent leaks
Speed & Performance 25% Speed retention, latency impact, consistency across servers 90%+ speed retention, <20ms added latency 70-90% speed retention, 20-40ms added latency 50-70% speed retention, 40-80ms added latency <50% speed retention, >80ms added latency
Server Network 20% Global coverage, server count, connection reliability 60+ countries, 3000+ servers, 99%+ reliability 40+ countries, 1000+ servers, 95%+ reliability 20+ countries, 500+ servers, 90%+ reliability <20 countries, <500 servers, <90% reliability
Features & Usability 15% App quality, device support, advanced features, ease of use Excellent apps on all platforms, advanced features Good apps on major platforms, useful features Basic apps, limited features, acceptable usability Poor apps, minimal features, difficult to use
Value & Support 10% Pricing, refund policy, customer support quality Competitive pricing, generous refund policy, excellent support Fair pricing, decent refund policy, good support Average pricing, limited refund, adequate support Expensive, restrictive refund, poor support

Additional Scoring Considerations

  • Bonus Points: Awarded for exceptional transparency, independent audits, or innovative features
  • Penalty Points: Deducted for privacy violations, security incidents, or misleading marketing
  • Regular Updates: All scores reviewed and updated quarterly to reflect service changes
  • Peer Review: All scores verified by multiple team members before publication

Our Commitment to Independence

While VPN Security Blog participates in affiliate programs, our testing methodology and scoring remain completely independent:

  • No Pay-for-Reviews: VPN providers cannot pay for reviews or influence scores
  • Identical Testing: All VPNs undergo identical testing procedures regardless of affiliate status
  • Transparent Disclosure: All affiliate relationships clearly disclosed on every review
  • Regular Audits: Internal audits ensure testing consistency and prevent bias
  • User Focus: Recommendations based solely on user benefit, not commission rates

Testing Methodology - FAQ

How long does each VPN test take?

Our comprehensive VPN testing process takes approximately 5-7 days per service. This includes 48 hours of continuous monitoring, speed tests across multiple servers and protocols, security vulnerability testing, and detailed analysis of privacy policies and company practices. Additional time may be required for follow-up testing or clarification with VPN providers.

What speed testing tools do you use?

We use multiple speed testing tools including Ookla Speedtest (industry standard), Fast.com (Netflix CDN), and custom scripts for consistency verification. Each VPN is tested 10 times per server with results averaged for accuracy. Testing occurs during both peak and off-peak hours to capture real-world performance variations.

How do you test VPN security?

We conduct comprehensive security testing including DNS leak tests (using DNSLeakTest.com and IPLeak.net), kill switch reliability testing under various failure scenarios, WebRTC leak detection, IPv6 leak testing, and network traffic analysis using Wireshark. We follow AMTSO VPN Performance Testing Guidelines for standardized methodology.

Do VPN companies pay for reviews?

Absolutely not. While we participate in affiliate programs to fund our testing, all VPNs undergo identical testing procedures regardless of partnership status. VPN providers cannot pay for reviews or influence scores. Our testing methodology, scoring criteria, and recommendations are based solely on technical performance and user benefit.

How often do you update VPN reviews?

We review and update all VPN scores quarterly to reflect service changes, new features, pricing updates, and security developments. Major changes trigger immediate retesting. We also monitor VPN providers continuously for security incidents, policy changes, or significant service modifications that would require review updates.

What makes your testing methodology different?

Our methodology follows the new AMTSO VPN Performance Testing Guidelines (industry standard), uses standardized hardware and network conditions, includes comprehensive kill switch robustness testing (including system reboot scenarios), and employs a transparent weighted scoring system. We're one of the few testing sites that publicly details our complete methodology.